Something is rotten in the state of Denmark

How can a team have five players moved up to 4.0 from 3.5 and then have ALL five payers bumped back down on appeal. Something indeed is rotten in the state of NEOTA. This was the talk and griping going on with the Super Senior teams that played on Thursday night. They were not talking about their own teams but a certain team in North Ridgeville that has dominated the league for the last 10 years . We all want fair play but this is peanutbutter. Who and How is it determined that an appeal is valid. We need some sunshine on this system.